New York Forces T-Mobile to Eliminate Data Caps on Low-Income Home Internet Plans
New York Forces T-Mobile to Eliminate Data Caps on Low-Income Home Internet Plans
New York state officials reached a settlement with T-Mobile after finding the company imposed illegal data caps on low-income broadband plans. The agreement requires T-Mobile to remove speed throttling, expand service availability, and improve plan visibility.
New York state officials have compelled T-Mobile to overhaul its low-income home internet offerings following an extensive investigation into regulatory violations. The Office of the Attorney General discovered that T-Mobile violated the state Affordable Broadband Act by imposing restrictive monthly data caps and severe speed throttling on subsidized broadband plans. Under the terms of the new settlement, the carrier must eliminate these restrictions, expand service availability across additional regions, and make plan details easily discoverable to eligible residents. The resolution marks a major milestone for state oversight of telecommunications providers.
The Affordable Broadband Act Violations
An investigation by the New York Office of the Attorney General revealed that T-Mobile failed to comply with state requirements governing low-income home internet service. Officials found that the company imposed a strict monthly data cap of fifty gigabytes on its affordable broadband plans, leading to aggressive speed throttling.
Once customers crossed this threshold, their download speeds plummeted drastically to levels as low as 650 kilobits per second. State leaders noted that typical household usage could easily exhaust this data allowance within just four days of normal internet activity.
Speed Throttling
Speeds were reduced to less than a megabit per second after exhausting the data allowance.
Restricted Access
T-Mobile limited low-income plans strictly to regions where 5G wireless was already deployed.
Hidden Information
Webpage coding specifically prevented search engines from indexing the affordable plan details.
Terms of the State Settlement
Under the finalized settlement agreement, T-Mobile must remove all data caps and speed limits from its low-income broadband offerings within 120 days. The company is also required to make these discounted plans available in all geographic areas throughout New York where it provides home internet services.
In addition to expanding geographic availability, T-Mobile agreed to ensure that search engines can freely index and access information regarding the Affordable Broadband Act plans. While agreeing to these comprehensive corrective measures, T-Mobile did not formally admit to any legal violations.
Legal Background and Enforcement
New York began enforcing the Affordable Broadband Act in January 2025 after successfully concluding a nearly four-year court battle. Major broadband industry groups, including the cellular trade association CTIA representing carriers like T-Mobile, had previously sued the state in an unsuccessful attempt to block the legislation.
The statute applies to home internet providers with at least 20,000 customers in the state. It mandates accessible pricing options for lower-income households, ensuring vulnerable residents can secure reliable broadband without facing predatory limitations or hidden fees.
Industry Pushback
Broadband lobby groups engaged in a multiyear court battle trying to block the New York law.
Provider Mandate
The regulation applies to any home internet provider operating with at least 20,000 customers.
Fixed Wireless Service Details
The regulatory enforcement specifically involves T-Mobile fixed wireless internet service, which functions as an alternative to traditional wired broadband infrastructure. This technology relies directly on cellular network towers to deliver internet connectivity to receivers installed at fixed customer residential locations.
Because the service utilizes wireless infrastructure, T-Mobile had initially restricted the affordable plans exclusively to zones featuring 5G deployment. The recent agreement forces the company to decouple low-income access from advanced 5G availability across the state.
Why It Matters
The enforcement action against T-Mobile highlights the ongoing regulatory challenges surrounding digital equity and subsidized telecommunications services. State authorities demonstrated that statutory mandates for affordable broadband require active oversight to prevent carriers from introducing covert limitations like data caps and restricted visibility. As fixed wireless home internet expands, ensuring equal access for low-income populations remains a critical priority for policymakers nationwide. This settlement establishes an important enforcement precedent for holding major carriers accountable to regional connectivity standards.
New York is forcing T-Mobile to stop putting data caps on low-income home internet plans (engadget.com) · T-Mobile illegally imposed 50GB cap on low-income home Internet plan, NY says (arstechnica.com)
Reporting reviewed through November 12, 2026.
